Detail & Scale Header
Digital Publications Link
Aviation Photo Section Link
Scale Modeling Section Link
Aviatin Artwork Link
Furball Aero Design / Detail & Scale Decals
About Us Link
Contact Us Link
Home Page Link

Detail & Scale Books

Quick Links to Available Detail & Scale Series Publications.


Detail & Scale Series


F3H Demon in
Detail & Scale
**********F2H Banshee in
Detail & Scale, Pt. 1

**********
SBD Dauntless in
Detail & Scale

**********

F-102 Delta Dagger in Detail & Scale
**********

F4F & FM Wildcat in Detail & Scale
**********

F-8 & RF-8 Crusader in Detail & Scale

**********

Military Aviation Websites:
Click Here

——————

Scale Modeling Websites:
Click Here



KIT REVIEW


Tamiya # 61114 F-14A Tomcat
1:48 Scale

For decades, the Grumman F-14 Tomcat has been a favorite among scale modelers, aviation enthusiasts, and aviators.  Over the years, there have been – by my count – no less than 385 different issues of F-14 kits from 1:144 to 1:32 scale.  The quality and accuracy of these kits varied, from early Airfix and Matchbox products to classic kits by Testors, Monogram, and Revell.  Generally, the best F-14 in 1:48 scale is often thought to be the Hasegawa family of Tomcats that first hit the market in 1988.  While they’re very good, the Hasegawa F-14s are also infamous for various construction glitches and ill-fitting parts.  Hobby Boss launched a more modern tooled and designed F-14 family in 2010.  Despite their promise, Hobby Boss Tomcats were plagued by rather misshapen intakes and notably inaccurate surface details.  In 2016, Tamiya finally stepped into the ring with a new-tool F-14 in 1:48 scale, looking to be a contender for the title of “Best 1:48 scale Tomcat.”  In this review, we’ll take a very careful look at this hotly anticipated kit.

(Return to top of page)

The F-14 Tomcat hardly needs an introduction, achieving fame through its 32 years of active duty and appearances in motion pictures such as Top Gun.  Tomcats played central roles in both relatively limited actions from the Gulf of Sidra to Grenada, Lebanon, and the so-called Persian Gulf Tanker War, to more historic events beginning with the evacuation of Saigon and Operations DESERT SHIELD/STORM, ALLIED FORCE, NOBLE EAGLE, ENDURING FREEDOM, and IRAQI FREEDOM.

Born from the ashes of the F-111B program of the late 1960s, the F-14 was originally conceived as a long-range interceptor fielding the AWG-9 radar/Phoenix missile combination, protecting U.S. Navy battle groups from long range Soviet bomber and cruise missile attacks.  The F-14 was also the first American aircraft to apply the hard lessons being learned in the Vietnam War, such the need for an internal cannon, 360 degrees of visibility, and excellent maneuverability.  It had a unique airframe, in part owing to its variable geometry (or swing) wings that quite literally changed the jet’s shape in the air to optimize for either high- or low-speed flight.  Particularly with its wings full forward, the F-14 was a potent dogfighter, famously capable of ‘bat turns’ that could allow the large interceptor to keep up with and gain the advantage over the most nimble of opponents.  With the development of the TARPS pod system, the Tomcat added aerial reconnaissance to its bag of tricks, and by the mid 1990s, it also evolved into outstanding strike fighter and forward air controller (informally nicknamed the “Bombcat”) with the addition of a LANTIRN targeting pod and precision laser- and GPS-guided munitions.

Grumman manufactured 712 Tomcats between 1970 and 1992 across three major variants. Most, of course, were F-14As fitted with the often-troubled and underpowered TF-30 engines.  The last U.S. Navy Tomcat was retired in September 2006 capping a celebrated 32 years of service which included five air-to-air victories and many thousands of tons of ordinance dropped and thousands of targets destroyed.  The Iranian Air Force still operates F-14As that were exported before the fall of the Shah in 1979.  During the Iran-Iraq war, Iranian F-14s reportedly shot down at least 160 Iraqi aircraft, though this figure has proven difficult to verify.  Iran’s remaining Tomcats (probably around 30 of the original 79 jets) have today been significantly overhauled and upgraded with Russian and Chinese assistance to probably fly on for another 10 years before they, too, are retired.

(Return to top of page)

Tamiya’s new tool F-14A represents an early production block Tomcat.  It comes in a sturdy box with just enough room for all the parts.  Eleven gray injection-molded sprues hold 373 plastic parts.  These include a full set of four Phoenix, four Sparrow, and two Sidewinder missiles along with a pair of drop tanks.  Six clear parts come on one clear sprue.  Pre-cut painting masks for the windscreen and canopy are also included (thanks, Tamiya!).  Two decal sheets cover the markings for three F-14As and airframe and missile stencils (including landing gear data placards).  The instruction booklet is accompanied by a foldout booklet summarizing the Tomcat’s history and loadout configurations in Japanese, English, German, and French.  A double-sided full-color painting and decal placement guide is also included for the following jets represented on the decal sheet:

- F-14A BuNo 160393, VF-84 Jolly Rogers CAG bird, USS NIMITZ, 1979

- F-14A BuNo 159625, VF-2 Bounty Hunters CO’s jet, USS ENTERPRISE, 1976

- F-14A BuNo 160377, Islamic Republic of Iran Air Force, Tactical Fighter Base 8,
  1980

Strengths: In addressing the strengths and weaknesses of this kit, I am looking at it through several different lenses – from that of a plastic model kit to be judged on its own merits to how it compares with other 1:48 scale F-14s and my own detailed knowledge of the Tomcat.

Just on its own merits, the Tamiya F-14A is a beautiful and exemplary kit – it’s truly a scale modeler’s kit.  It features excellent molding, elegant recessed panel line and fastener/rivet detail, and a high fidelity of accurate detail on parts such as the cockpit, ejection seats, intake ramps engine exhaust nozzles, and missiles.  Comparing these with my various sets of F-14 line drawings, this new Tamiya kit appears to be very size and shape accurate.  Also, the jets represented on the decal sheet are early Block 74, 75, and 76 F-14As.  Tamiya accurately represents the configuration of these Tomcats, from the configuration of the gun gas purge vents on the port side of the nose, to the sole AN/ALQ-100 chin pod, early-style wheel hubs, and the vertical stabilizer fin cap stiffeners. All are correct for Block 74-76 F-14As.  Tamiya nailed it.  The attendant depth of research that Tamiya devoted to this kit is very clear.

I’m also quite happy to say that the various shortcomings of both the venerable Hasegawa kit and more recent Hobby Boss kit have not been repeated in the Tamiya F-14A.  Locating tabs for the rear of the intakes, the forward fuselage to mid-fuselage joint design, and the one-piece boat tail will clearly prevent the kinds of ugly fits that one can run into in the Hasegawa kits.  And, unlike the Hobby Boss kit, Tamiya indeed got the shape of the intakes right (whew – that’s a relief!).  Also, the placement of fastener and rivet details throughout the airframe is correct and achieves greater accuracy than the Hasegawa kit, which is to say a lot.  Regarding the Hobby Boss kit, the “Mad Riveter” visited that F-14 kit:  Hobby Boss placed hundreds of rivets on the wings, horizontal stabilizers, and aft upper fuselage where they do not exist on the real airplane.  Again, Tamiya got the rivets right, showing their consistent attention to detail and accuracy.  Other details, such as the flap hinges and correct spoiler geometry, long neglected by other 1:48 kits, are well represented here.

My test fitting of the nose/forward fuselage halves, upper and lower fuselages, wings, and intake assemblies revealed an airtight fit.  We’re talking literally seamless fits that require no filler.  This kit appears to be beautifully engineered in this respect, and Brett Green’s progressive build review over on Hyperscale confirms this observation.  The cockpit is quite good and I am impressed with the various things that Tamiya has chosen to do a little differently regarding the parts breakdown of this kit.

For example, there’s an inner framework that the wings slip over to help ensure proper dihedral and left-right wing alignment.  Also a little different is the fact that the radome and forward fuselage are single left and right halves.  Most other comparable F-14 kits have the radome as a separate single part that of course invites fit errors.  In fact, what Tamiya has done here is to effectively address the often-troubled radome-nose fit that builders would encounter in the Hasegawa kits.  The cockpit sills and rear decking is a single-piece frame that drops right down onto the edges of the cockpit – a very nice concept that no one else has ever done in a Tomcat kit.  The refueling probe may be displayed deployed or retracted, similar to the Hobby Boss kit.  Also, the forward windscreen is molded as part of a larger extended part that includes the sides and front of the upper nose, eliminating the often tedious and challenging prospect of gluing, fairing in, and seam-filling of the windscreen’s edges in the Hasegawa kit.

I really like the parts breakdown for the nose and main landing gear.  Not only are the parts quite accurate but their design also ensures a fairly excellent fit between all the ‘fiddly’ smaller braces and oleos as well as the gear assembly’s fit to the fuselage.  The inner and outer sides of the main nose gear doors are molded as separate parts, and the inner half, along with analogous parts for the main gear well doors, have the gear door actuators molded as part of the inner surface of the door.  Again, no one has done this before on an F-14 kit.  The approach works very well in my opinion, and the molded-in actuators also contribute to making sure the doors fit true.  A few other features might remind you of Tamiya’s 1:32 F-14, such as the way the forward and aft upper fuselage are separate parts that come together in a V-shaped configuration and the way the wing sweep mechanism works.

There are clear signs that other versions of the Tamiya Tomcat are planned.  There’s a clear modular approach to variant-specific gun gas purge vents, boat tail, chin pod, and aft fuselage engine assembly, Phoenix pallets with modular fittings that can fit a BRU-32 bomb rack, and the inclusion of unused parts for AIM-9Ls.  If this is a correct reading of the parts breakdown, we can surely look forward to later -A models, the GE-powered F-14B and -Ds, and parts for air-to-ground loadouts seen on Tomcats between 1995 and 2006.

The decals appear to have been printed in-house by Tamiya, and they’re beautiful.  Perfectly in register, the print quality is vibrant and captures some very intricate designs such as the detail on the Iranian flag and various stencils.  Carrier film looks thin and is precisely laid down on the edges of the printed ink.

An observation of interest: if you're like me, you’ve got a pile of aftermarket decals for the F-14, and most in the industry are sized for the Hasegawa kit in mind.  Fortunately, comparison of this new Tamiya F-14 and the Hasegawa Tomcat show nearly identically sized parts, though the Hasegawa vertical stabilizer fin cap is 1.41 millimeters taller.  However, the Hasegawa’s rudders are slightly higher. This means that if you have other early F-14 markings that you’d like to use in lieu of the kit decals, there should be virtually no problems making most of them fit on the Tamiya Tomcat.  The only exception would decals that are sized to cover the Hasegawa rudders (say, a VF-211 checkerboard) would likely require some trimming to properly fit on the Tamiya Tomcat.

Weaknesses:  There are only a few critiques that can be considered for this superlative kit. Interestingly, my primary critique simultaneously reflects one of the Tamiya Tomcat’s unqualified strengths and this line of commentary borders on the philosophical.  This is a beautiful kit, designed for ease of build and is underscored by streamlined, clean model kit engineering.  We’re talking high levels of builder enjoyment here.  But this also means the kit lacks the kind of building options that many scale modelers have enjoyed in the Hasegawa and Hobby Boss Tomcats. I like choice and the possibilities that brings to a build.  Here, the wings are single pieces with retracted slats and flaps and there’s no option to extend/drop them.  The same applies to the molded-in upper and lower speed brakes.  These elements of the kit may remind you as to how the older Monogram, Revell, and Academy F-14s were designed.  So, if you wish to build your F-14 with the wings either swept back or motored forward in a clean configuration – seriously, look no further!  This is your F-14 kit in 1:48 scale.  If you want to build a “dirty Turkey,” the only recourse is a lesser kit.

Also, while the glove vanes are represented in the retracted position by panel lines, there are no glove vane parts to model them in the extended position.  The variable geometry intake ramps can only be built in their retracted position (how they sit when the jet is parked or flying at subsonic airspeed) and there are no alternative parts to configure the ramps in their transonic or supersonic positions (though it would be easy to do it yourself, repositioning them with stretched sprue or stock plastic rod ramp actuators).

Other observations reflect varying degrees of Tomcat geek-level minutia, but in the interest of evaluating accuracy and doing so dispassionately, let’s take a look at them.  Tamiya seems to have made the choice to simplify some details.  While the cockpit is really outstanding for an injection molded kit, a few of the very fine switch details and positions seem either just a little simplified or a little off-scale – but to be clear, it’s not too noticeable.  Also, the throttles are molded contiguous to the cockpit tub and are pretty inaccurate in terms of shape.  I wonder if it were produced as a separate part that a better throttle could have been achieved.  The rear cockpit decking is devoid of detail (there’s a fair amount going back there by the canopy hinge).  Of course, all of this this opens the door to aftermarket superdetail parts which will be surely on the way.

Other simplified areas of the kit are the boarding ladder (again, well done for injection molding but still inaccurate, and one would argue the F-14’s intricate folding boarding ladder structure can really only be best represented by photoetch metal parts).  Also, the gear wells walls are nearly totally devoid of the extensive plumbing and wiring details along with the very prominent rivets that, for better or worse, other 1:48 scale kits have tried to represent.  In that respect, Tamiya gives the modeler an option to work in those details themselves.

The GRU-7A ejection seats are a mixed bag.  On one hand, they are rather accurate.  The seat pads depict the early ribbed cushions, so that’s fine for this early F-14A kit.  However, the shoulder harnesses and seat belts are provided only as decals. While decal belts are not my personal preference, they can be considered inconsistent with the high level of molded detail seen on other parts.

Ultra-Tomcat minutia (or, things only a plane captain should notice): the inflatable wing sweep airbags aft of the wing are nicely represented and are the first in any scale to correctly represent the grommets and screws on the upper edges of the bag’s cover.  However, those extend down to the side edges of the bag, and those small details are missing here. The inboard aft main gear well wall (inboard of where the main landing gear attaches to the plane) curves quite noticeably inward following the contour of the roof of the intake trunk.  The Tamiya gear well wall is a rarity among 1:48 F-14 kits, as it recognizes that contour, but it curves in more like a dimple – Tamiya had the right idea, just not nearly enough.  It’s nice to see that the canopy hooks are represented on the insides of the canopy, but they’re foreshortened and don’t extend below the edge of the rail as they do on the jet.  Also, in looking at the AIM-54 stencils, the same SERNO (or serial number marking) is repeated for all the AIM-54s.  Each missile had a unique identifying SERNO, so they should be different.

Lastly, do keep a vigilant eye out for ejection pin markings on various parts, such as inside surfaces of landing gear doors.

(Return to top of page)

Overall, Tamiya has produced a superlative F-14 Tomcat kit.  It is clearly the best engineered and best fitting F-14 in 1:48 scale to date, and it also possess the most accurate surface detail.  It goes beyond the Hasegawa and Hobby Boss F-14s in these respects.  Yet, it’s not quite perfect, and the limitations regarding construction choices do cut back on the range of possibilities for the scale modeler. That said, this is one beautiful F-14, and I cannot wait to begin building mine.  While the title for “Best-Ever F-14 Kit” may still be unclaimed in my opinion, Tamiya’s new Tomcat comes so very close.

Many sincere thanks are owed to Tamiya America and George Canare for their generosity in sharing this review sample with us. You can find them on the web at https://www.facebook.com/TamiyaUSA on the web at tamiyausa.com.  Also, thanks go out to Dave Baranek, Bill Barto, and Brian Marbrey who provided valuable input, photos, and drawings that greatly assisted this review.

Haagen Klaus
Scale Modeling News & Reviews Editor
Detail & Scale

(Return to top of page)

** Click on the thumbnails below to view a larger image.**


   

(Return to top of page)

Just Released!

JET FIGHTERS
OF THE U. S. NAVY AND MARINE CORPS
PART 1: THE FIRST TEN YEARS
*********

Detail & Scale Special Edition Books

U. S. Navy and Marine Carrier-Based Aircraft of World War II
*********


Attack on Pearl Harbor, Japan Awakens a Sleeping Giant

********


Colors & Markings Series



Colors & Markings of U. S. Navy
F-14 Tomcats,
Part 1: Atlantic
Coast Squadrons
********


Colors & Markings of the F-102
Delta Dagger

**********


Colors & Markings of U. S. Navy
F-14 Tomcats,
Part 2: Pacific
Coast Squadrons

**********